How to File an Insurance Claim Correctly

Filing an insurance claim properly can mean the difference between quick payment and denial. Follow these exact steps for auto, home, health, or life insurance claims, with documentation checklists and timeline tips to avoid delays and maximize your settlement.

Step-by-Step Claim Filing Process

Step 1: Immediate Actions (First 24-48 Hours)

Ensure Safety First

• Auto accidents: Move to safety, check for injuries, call 911 if needed
• Home damage: Evacuate if unsafe, shut off utilities if necessary
• Health emergencies: Get medical attention first, insurance second
• Theft: File police report immediately

Mitigate Further Damage

Your policy requires you to prevent additional damage when reasonably possible:

• Cover broken windows with plywood or tarps
• Shut off water for plumbing leaks
• Remove water to prevent mold
• Secure the property against further theft
• Keep receipts for emergency repairs and mitigation costs

Step 2: Review Your Policy

Before calling your insurer, understand your coverage:

Key Policy Information to Find

• Coverage limits: What's the maximum payout?
• Deductibles: What will you pay out-of-pocket?
• Covered perils: Is this type of damage included?
• Exclusions: What's specifically not covered?
• Time limits: How long do you have to file?
• Special requirements: Police reports, appraisals, etc.

Step 3: Contact Your Insurance Company

When to Call

• Immediately: For major losses, injuries, or theft
• Within 24-48 hours: For property damage
• Before any repairs: Unless emergency mitigation

Information to Have Ready

• Policy number and effective dates
• Date, time, and location of incident
• Brief description of what happened
• Police report number (if applicable)
• Contact information for other parties involved
• Estimated damage or loss amount

What the Insurer Will Tell You

• Claim number: Write this down and reference in all communications
• Adjuster assignment: Who will handle your claim
• Next steps: Documentation needed, inspection scheduling
• Rental car info: For auto claims with coverage
• Preferred repair shops: In-network options

Step 4: Document Everything

Specific Documentation by Claim Type

Auto Accident Claims

• Photos of all vehicles, damage, accident scene
• Police report number
• Other driver's insurance information
• Witness contact information
• Medical treatment records

Home Insurance Claims

• Photos/video of damage from multiple angles
• Home inventory with serial numbers
• Purchase receipts for damaged items
• Contractor repair estimates
• Hotel receipts if displaced

Health Insurance Claims

• Medical bills and treatment records
• Prescription receipts
• Explanation of Benefits (EOB) forms
• Provider network verification
• Pre-authorization documentation

Step 5: Working with Adjusters

Types of Adjusters

• Staff adjusters: Employees of insurance company
• Independent adjusters: Contractors hired by insurer
• Public adjusters: Hired by you to represent your interests

The Adjuster Meeting

When the adjuster inspects your damage:

• Be present: Point out all damage
• Take notes: Record what the adjuster says and does
• Ask questions: About coverage, process, timeline
• Provide documentation: Give copies, keep originals
• Don't sign anything without reading and understanding

What Adjusters Look For

• Cause of damage: Is it covered under your policy?
• Extent of damage: What needs repair or replacement?
• Pre-existing damage: What was damaged before this incident?
• Mitigation efforts: Did you prevent further damage?
• Policy compliance: Did you meet all requirements?

Step 6: Track All Communications

Communication Log

Keep detailed records of every interaction:

Written Confirmation

Follow up important phone conversations with email:

"Per our phone conversation today at 2:30 PM, I understand that my claim #ABC123 will be assigned to an adjuster within 48 hours. Please confirm if this timeline is accurate."

Step 7: Settlement and Payment

Understanding Settlement Offers

Your insurer will provide a settlement breakdown showing:

• Actual Cash Value (ACV) or replacement cost
• Less deductible
• Less depreciation (if ACV policy)
• Less prior payments (rental car, etc.)

Replacement Cost Claims Process

For replacement cost policies, you typically receive payment in two stages:

1. Initial payment: Actual cash value minus deductible
2. Final payment: Remaining replacement cost after you complete repairs

When to Negotiate

Consider negotiating if:

• Settlement seems low compared to repair estimates
• Adjuster missed damage during inspection
• You have evidence of higher values
• Comparable sales/replacements cost more

Claim-Specific Tips

Auto Insurance Claims

• Don't admit fault at the scene or to adjusters
• Get multiple repair estimates if using your own shop
• Understand total loss calculations (ACV vs. amount owed)
• Review rental car coverage limits and time restrictions

Home Insurance Claims

• Don't throw away damaged items until adjuster sees them
• Get detailed contractor estimates including labor and materials
• Understand code upgrade coverage (ordinance and law)
• Document additional living expenses if displaced

Health Insurance Claims

• Verify network providers before treatment when possible
• Get prior authorization for expensive procedures
• Keep copies of all bills and explanation of benefits
• Appeal denied claims with additional medical records

Common Mistakes That Hurt Claims

• Late notification: Waiting too long to file
• Inadequate documentation: Poor photos, missing receipts
• Admitting fault: Especially in auto accidents
• Not mitigating damage: Allowing preventable additional damage
• Accepting first offer: Without reviewing thoroughly
• Making unauthorized repairs: Before adjuster inspection
• Providing recorded statements without preparation
• Not reading settlement documents before signing

When to Get Professional Help

Consider a Public Adjuster When:

• Claim is large ($50,000+)
• Damage assessment seems too low
• Claim is complex (business interruption, etc.)
• You're overwhelmed by the process
• Initial claim was denied

Consider an Attorney When:

• Claim involves serious injuries
• Bad faith claim handling
• Significant disputes over coverage
• Multiple denied appeals

Related Guides